Let’s be real, going to a coffee shop is like 70% about the flavor selection. Pumpkin-spice this, french vanilla that. But what if you could get those fancy flavors at home? Obvious plot twist: You can. We partnered with baristas and home cooks to bring you 15 homemade coffee creamer recipes so good, you may never leave your house again.
Homemade Coffee Creamer Recipes You Can Make Today
We’re talking all the good stuff. Copycat versions of your go-to flavors, dairy-free and vegan options, and even some fun surprises. Basically, if you like your coffee extra, there’s a creamer here for you. Let’s do this.
1. Reese’s Coffee Creamer
Meet the Beyoncé and Jay-Z of the flavor universe: chocolate and peanut butter.
This copycat Reese’s Coffee Creamer combines cocoa powder, peanut butter, sweetened condensed milk, and vanilla into a creamy, dreamy delight.
Add to hot or iced coffee for life’s least shareable dessert.
RECIPE: Reese’s Coffee Creamer
2. Homemade Salted Caramel Coffee Creamer
Salty! Sweet! Actually, it’s completely irresistible!
Real talk: this homemade salted caramel coffee creamer will knock your socks off. Why? It’s made with REAL caramel sauce, milk, heavy cream, and a tiny splash of vanilla. Plus sea salt. No barista required.
RECIPE: Homemade Salted Caramel Coffee Creamer
3. White Chocolate Coffee Syrup
White chocolate people, this is not a drill! This White Chocolate Coffee Syrup takes your caffeine situation into liquid dessert territory.
Made with white chocolate chips, milk, and a touch of vanilla, it swirls seamlessly into hot coffee and makes iced lattes feel downright fancy.
Extra whipped cream? Yes, please!
RECIPE: White Chocolate Coffee Syrup
4. Dairy Free Pumpkin Spice Creamer
Pumpkin spice season? Nah, we’re talking pumpkin spice LIFE.
This dairy-free creamer is a pure blend of real pumpkin, warm spices, and coconut milk. No yucky additives, just that dreamy spiced latte swag.
Save the drama for your llama—just sip on this pumpkin daydream for autumn perfection.
RECIPE: Dairy-Free Pumpkin Spice Creamer
5. Homemade Powdered Coffee Creamer
Running out of creamer is a caffeine emergency and this powdered version is the perfect backup plan.
Made with powdered milk, powdered sugar, and a little coconut oil, this mix is ready for your morning cup.
No fridge, no fuss. Just scoop, stir, and enjoy with a smug look on your face.
RECIPE: Homemade Powdered Coffee Creamer
6. Simple Coffee Creamer Recipe
Minimalism never looked (or tasted) so good.
This homemade creamer is just sweetened condensed milk, milk, and vanilla, but don’t let the simplicity fool you, it’s smooth, creamy perfection in a cup.
Great for those whose wallets can’t support their coffee shop habits.
RECIPE: Simple Coffee Creamer Recipe
7. Peppermint Mocha Creamer
Who decided peppermint mocha is a December-only thing?
This creamer mixes up cocoa powder, peppermint extract, and sweetened condensed milk for a chocolatey-minty cup o’ magic. Use it to festive-ify your life—or just caffeinate it.
Extra chocolate drizzle? The answer is always very yes.
RECIPE: Peppermint Mocha Creamer
8. DIY Pumpkin Spice Creamer
Listen. In our hearts, PSL season never dies. And now it’s happening in your coffee.
This homemade Pumpkin Spice Creamer has real pumpkin purée, warm spices, and maple syrup. There’s also a sugar-free option for guilt-free fall vibes.
Legit cozy vibes, guaranteed.
RECIPE: DIY Pumpkin Spice Creamer
9. Dunkin Hazelnut Swirl Copycat
Hankering for that Dunkin’ Hazelnut Swirl but feeling way too Netflix-and-blanket to leave the house?
This homemade version is your best bet, with creaminess from sweetened condensed milk, water, and hazelnut syrup.
Mix into coffee and freak out because you just made coffee shop-quality coffee at home.
RECIPE: Dunkin Hazelnut Swirl Copycat
10. Gingerbread Coffee Creamer
BRB, putting this cozy beverage on repeat.
You might say half-and-half, molasses, cinnamon, ginger, and cloves transform your coffee into a warm, sweet + spicy cup of holiday magic. You might also say your fav gingerbread jumped off a cookie sheet and straight into your mug.
RECIPE: Gingerbread Coffee Creamer
11. Homemade Blueberry Coffee Creamer
If you like blueberry muffins, prepare to fall MADLY, DEEPLY in love.
This creamer combines half & half, heavy cream, blueberry extract, and vanilla for a smooth & slightly fruity flavor that’s just a lil sweet, a lil creamy, and a whole lot delicious. It’s kind of like drinking your bakery treat without any crumbs.
RECIPE: Homemade Blueberry Coffee Creamer
12. 2-Ingredient Walnut Coffee Creamer
Step aside, basic additives. Blended walnuts and water are a two-ingredient coffee game-changer.
This vegan blaze of nut-filled creaminess is keto-friendly and dairy-free, giving your morning cup a hint of smooth, nutty flavor.
Inject some gourmet jazz in 5 minutes flat without leaving your house.
RECIPE: 2-Ingredient Walnut Coffee Creamer
13. Oat Milk Creamer
Oat milk lovers, this one’s calling your name. This homemade oat milk creamer is thick, smooth, and blends like a dream.
Made with rolled oats, water, and a touch of hemp seed oil, it’s dairy-free and naturally sweet.
Want to switch it up? Add vanilla or cinnamon for extra cozy vibes.
RECIPE: Oat Milk Creamer
14. Milk Chocolate Coffee Creamer
Chocolate in my coffee? Oh, always.
This homemade milk chocolate creamer mixes cocoa powder, dry milk powder, and sugar to make the most luscious treat everrrrr. Stir it in and instant mocha-fication is achieved without the coffee shop.
Great for those times when your sweet tooth and caffeine craving are equally intense.
RECIPE: Milk Chocolate Coffee Creamer
15. Vegan Coffee Creamer
Dairy-free, creamy, dreamy.
This vegan coffee creamer is soaked almonds blended with water, vanilla, and a touch of sweetness.
Smooth, slightly nutty, and the best way to finish any cup of coffee. Zero additives, no dairy, just pure plant goodness in every slurp.
RECIPE: Vegan Coffee Creamer
Wrapping It Up
Homemade coffee creamer? A 10/10 idea. Flavor control! Money saved! Because let’s face it, store-bought creamers are not cheap.
Once you nail the basics, you can start experimenting with new flavors and become your own at-home barista. So proud of you!
